PAPER REVIEW FORM

GLOBAL MEDIA JOURNAL
(AMERICAN EDITION)
www.globalmediajournal.com
Email to:  Guest Editor/s (Insert name, email, and fax number here)
Reviewer: ________________________
Paper Title: _______________________
Dear Reviewer:
Please read the following mission statement of the Global Media Journal, and evaluate the submitted paper by responding to the questions that follows.  Please return your comments by ______________ (Date).

Global Media Journal publishes works that assess existing media structures and practices, such as global media concentration, globalization of TV genres, global media and consumer culture, the role of media in democratic governance and global justice, propaganda, media reception and cultural practice, commercialization of news, new media technologies, media regulations, regional media, alternative media, and other timely issues.

INSTRUCTIONS:
Using the following scale, please review this paper.

1. Poor                 2. Satisfactory             3.  Good          4. Excellent     5. Not applicable

Please circle a value in each category.
a. Significance of topic                                                                 1   2   3   4   5
b. Thoroughness of literature review                                             1   2   3   4   5
c. Theoretical/conceptual development                                         1   2   3   4   5
d. Soundness of methodology                                                      1   2   3   4   5
e. Usefulness of findings/conclusions                                             1   2   3   4   5
f. Writing style/organization                                                          1   2   3   4   5

Do you recommend publication of this article in the Global Media Journal?
Yes                        No                   Yes with changes

COMMENTS:

Return to Home | Return to Top