|
Article No. 9
A Reception Analysis: Latina Teenagers Talk About
Telenovelas[i]
Kristin C. Moran
University of San Diego
kmoran@sandiego.edu
Abstract
As the population of Latino teenagers continues to
grow in the U.S., it is important for researchers to look at what
they may be learning about from television programming. This project
studies a particular interpretive community to determine the role
entertainment in Latina teenagers’ understanding of romantic
relationships in the United States. The findings show that the
teenagers actively use the mass media to reaffirm their own system
of values and judged the characters’ promiscuous behavior as wrong.
Scholars and the general public have debated the
influence of television on society since the medium was invented.
Television’s role in people’s lives has been described as all
powerful or dismissed as nothing more than a quiet diversion,
depending on the point of view. What we do know is that television
is an important cultural force for an increasingly diverse
population. It is my feeling that the influence of television lies
between the two extremes -- somewhere on the continuum that is
actually impossible to pinpoint because television, as a social
force, must be included with all the other factors that create one’s
persona. In other words, television influences how persons
understand themselves and the world around, but it is the nature of
that influence that fuels this project.
The cultural environment of adolescents, especially
in Southern California, has changed to include a large group of
Latinos. This ever-increasing segment of the population has not been
ignored by the television industry. Spanish language networks have
expanded and developed to serve this growing audience. The most
popular network in Southern California is Univision. Televisa, the
largest broadcasting network in Mexico owns 25% of Univsion
(Rodriquez, 2003). Univision’s popularity among Spanish-speaking
households is evidenced by its 37 percent share of the
Hispanic/Latino audience (Univision Press Packet, 1999). Nearly 70
percent of Univision’s audience is Mexican or Mexican American
(Rodriquez, 2003). Teenagers are, of course, part of this group.
Univision, like its English language counterparts, has created
programs that attract teenagers to the set. The popular Spanish
language network has attracted the teen audience with telenovelas
that deal with teen issues, such as dating, peer pressure, drug use
and parental issues, while using young actors to provide
identifiable characters for this audience.
Like most dramatic prime-time fare, telenovelas
typically revolve around romantic relationships and sexual
interactions -- whether explicit or implicit. And for their part,
teenagers are interested in learning about their sexuality, but
often cultural norms make it uncomfortable for adolescents to ask
questions about the very thing that is often on their mind. The mass
media offer an easy and prolific source of answers to the questions
teens are often too embarrassed to ask out loud.
Accordingly, researchers have, for decades,
investigated the potential impact media representations of sexual
activity have on child and adolescent’s understanding of sexuality.
Television programs are a cultural text that may teach young viewers
cultural norms and expectations and, thus, ways to interact in daily
life, specifically related to dating and intimate relationships. The
primary result of this inquiry, however, has been to reveal the
complex nature of audience interaction with media content.
Content analysis studies in the United States
related to sexual activity have focused on predominantly Caucasian
audiences watching American made soap operas (see for example,
Heintz-Knowles, et al., 1997; Greenberg and Busselle, 1994).
Nevertheless, it is important to include in the study of television
effects an increasing population of Latin Americans who are watching
entertainment television. Cultural differences in both the content
and of the audience are factors that cannot be ignored. It is a
mistake to take research conducted on Caucasians and content
targeted especially to them and apply it to Americans with different
cultural backgrounds.
The teenage population is changing in America and,
as with all age groups, teenagers are more culturally diverse. The
rate of growth among the Latino population is greater than for any
other minority group. Latino owned businesses are increasing and
their economic and political power is changing the face of the
United States. The growth of the Latino minority has encouraged the
mass media industry to serve their needs by providing
Spanish-language programming. The television network Univision has
become one of the most popular networks for Spanish-speaking
audiences, receiving a 37 percent viewing share of Hispanic
households in the United States from September 1997 through May 1998
(Univision Press Packet, 1999).
The theoretical foundation of this study comes
mainly from Social Learning Theory and Active Audience Theory. Each
of these perspectives provides information about the potential
effects of television content on audiences. Social Learning Theory
explains how teenagers may imitate the observed behavior shown on
television while Active Audience Theory provides insight into how
audiences interpret and interact with the mass media.
Nariman (1993), who studied the impact of
telenovelas on audiences explains: "...the largest portion of
learning involving one’s adaptation to society takes place through
such observational learning" (p. 38), especially when it comes to
new experiences. If a teenager has little or no experience with an
activity the observational learning from others becomes more
important. Brown and Steele (1995) add that:
Modeling will occur more regularly when the model is
perceived as attractive and is similar to the imitator and the
modeled behavior is salient, simple, prevalent, has functional value
and is possible. Thus, the theory would predict that teens who spend
more time watching television will imitate behavior that includes
depictions of attractive characters having sexual intercourse who
rarely suffer any negative consequences (Brown and Steele, 1995, p.
22).
Social learning theory, therefore, provides the
foundations to study the possibility that teens will imitate the
behavior of characters in telenovelas with whom they identify --
specifically teenagers and young adults. The characters seen in
Spanish-language programming may be particularly attractive to young
Latina viewers since images of Hispanic characters on traditional
American television are few.
A trend in audience research has been to use
qualitative methodologies to uncover how audience members interact
with the mass media. Klaus Jensen (1987) explains that qualitative
audience research can better reveal how viewers make their own sense
of the media based on their personal circumstances.
Buckingham (1998) explains that much previous
research on adolescents and television has neglected the notions of
this active response. He states:
The notion that children might actively construct
meanings from what they watch, and that those meanings might be
diverse or ambiguous -- let alone that socialization itself might be
an equally uncertain and contested process -- is only now beginning
to be recognized (p. 27).
Meaning is dynamic and happens as a result of the
interaction between the message and receiver. The idea of active
reception now fuels much of the research on audience interpretation.
The perceptions of the audience member includes his or her social
and cultural surroundings, as well as what is occurring during the
viewing of a certain television program. Everything about the
context of the interaction between the viewer and the message can
influence the interpretation of that message. Moores (1990) concurs
that the key to any study regarding reception is the inclusion of
the contextual framework of the audience.
Darcy Haag Granello (1997) conducted a reception
study with adolescent girls focusing on their interpretation of
Beverly Hills, 90210. She emphasizes that the interpretation of the
text, while active is not completely subjective. Discussing meaning
she states:
Although not universal, neither is the meaning
decoded from the text wholly individually subjective. It is
intersubjective. The female viewers must decode and produce a
relevant meaning from 90210, and they do not decode that meaning in
a social vacuum. They are influenced by their social experiences,
their life experiences, and their developmental stages (Granello,
1997, p. 27).
While these studies point to the audience’s
potential to assign multiple meaning to texts, Granello (1997)
points out there are ideological barriers that keep the
interpretations within the dominant ideology. Morley (1993) agrees
that audience members are operating within a dominant ideology so
the choices of their readings are still within an ideological
framework. Further, Morley (1993) argues to be mindful of the
"difference between having power over a text, and power over the
agenda within which that text is constructed and presented" (p. 14).
In the case of audience studies, the research needs to understand
the relationship between how media content is produced and the
ideological messages imbedded in the text and social formations
surrounding audience interpretation to truly get at how people
understand and use the mass media.
This study hopes to contribute to our understanding
of American Latina teenagers as a unique interpretive community by
analyzing the content of televisions programs they watch (telenovelas)
and hearing, in their own words, their perceptions of that content.
The undertaking of this project is not to uncover the direct effects
of sexually explicit content on adolescent viewers, but rather to
provide new insight into the relationship between television content
and audiences by conducting a reception analysis that pays
particular attention to the interpretive strategies used by Latina
teenagers. It addresses the following research question: What
interpretive strategies do Latina teenagers rely on to understand
romantic relationships seen on telenovelas?
Method
This project assesses the audience’s interpretation
of the messages imparted by telenovelas through a reception analysis
that provides a more comprehensive understanding of the relationship
between adolescents and television viewing. A reception analysis
will provide the opportunity to learn when and why these teens turn
to the media for information.
It is clear that concern over the potential effects
of mass media has spurred audience research since the first messages
were disseminated to a mass audience. What has changed over time are
the methods used to uncover the effects, and the assumptions
underlying these studies. The tradition of audience research has
moved from empirical data collection to include a more integrated
approach that includes qualitative analysis of both the content and
audience reception.
As with any research that is intercultural, careful
consideration of ethnic differences needs to be taken before the
initial communication. As a researcher, I have been fortunate to
have been introduced to the Latin culture both in Spain and Mexico,
as well as to Latinos living in Southern California. Nevertheless,
special care was taken to ensure that I did not offend or hinder the
data collection process by being unaware of cultural norms or
standards. In addition to the differences between the culture of the
participants and my own, I had to take into consideration that the
participants were teenagers. Because they were younger, I had to
make sure to use language that was not only culturally appropriate,
but also appropriate for their age group.
Before the formal interviews and focus groups, I
spent time with Latina girls talking about their likes and dislikes
in regard to television and life in general. I discovered through
these interactions how the teens interacted and was able to learn
some specific slang words that I could use during future data
collection. The time spent with the teens was invaluable, as I
learned not only what they like to watch on television, but I also
gained their trust during these informal interactions.
Although the teenagers in my study attend high
school in the United States, and speak fluent English, I needed to
be aware of specific cultural norms that might influence the data
collection process. An aspect of Hispanic culture that is important
to this study is what Marín and Marín (1991) call simpatía;
Simpatía emphasizes the need for behaviors that
promote smooth and pleasant social relationships. As a script,
simpatía moves the individual to show a certain level of conformity
and empathy for the feelings of other people (p. 12).
This became crucial when talking to the teenagers
about a sensitive subject like intimate relationships.
Another cultural characteristic, familialism (Marín
and Marín, 1990, p. 13), was particularly relevant during the data
collection process. The authors describe this value as a way to
understand the closeness and attachment that is common among Latino
families. Familialism includes not only the nuclear family, but also
a large extended family. In terms of this research project,
familialism is important because many teenagers watch telenovelas
with other family members. In addition, their strong family ties
influence their interpretations of the characters’ actions.
The sample of focus group/interview participants
included twenty-four teenagers from middle-upper class families who
attend private Catholic high schools. The homogeneity of the sample
of teenagers limits the discussion about the role of television
viewing to this specific sub-set of Latina teenagers. While the
findings can not be used to discuss the larger population of
teenagers, the goal of a reception analysis is to uncover in-depth
information about a particular audience. Therefore, the homogeneity
of the sample is not only an asset because it allows for an analysis
of the interpretive elements that may be common across this group of
teens, but also a main premise of reception analysis. Furthermore,
their socio-economic status makes them similar to the characters on
the television programs which may lead to interpretations based on
their ability to identify with certain situations (McQuail, 1994).
While the focus group/interview questions do not
directly ask the teenagers to describe their own personal sexual
activity, many volunteered that they were sexually inexperienced and
planned to save themselves until marriage. Their lack of experience
may make them more susceptible to the potentially incorrect or
fantasized version of romantic relationships depicted on
telenovelas.
Two focus groups were conducted at the Academy of
Our Lady of Peace High School in San Diego, California in October
1999. Permission to conduct the focus groups was granted by Dr.
Melinda Blade, Social Studies Department Chairperson and Sister
Dolores Anchondo. The form and line of questioning was approved by
the Human Subjects Committee at the University of Washington. In
addition, each teen who participated in the focus groups returned a
consent/assent form signed by her parent.
The first focus group consisted of seven Latina
teenagers who expressed interest and familiarity with telenovelas.
The second group started with nine teenagers, but one teen needed to
leave before the conclusion of the focus group. Both focus groups
were conducted in a classroom at the high school and lasted
approximately 50 minutes. The comfortable and familiar setting
helped to relax the participants and allowed them to speak freely
about their impressions of telenovelas.
A third focus group was conducted at University of
San Diego High School in November 1999. The focus group was
conducted after school in a classroom that was familiar to the
students. There were eight participants. The focus group lasted
approximately 60 minutes. Permission was granted by Melinda Berry,
the student’s math teacher and Timothy Berenthal, the assistant
Principal. Again, each student was given a consent/assent form that
was signed by her parent.
All of the participants were fluent in both Spanish
and English and were frequent viewers of telenovelas. The ethnic
background was dominantly Mexican although one teen made it clear
she was Puerto Rican. All the teenagers were between the ages of 14
and 18 years old.
A total of eight in-depth interviews were also
conducted. One interview was with a respondent who did not
participate in the focus groups. The interview was conducted at a
local restaurant and lasted approximately 90 minutes. The other
seven interviews were conducted with Latinas who did participate in
the focus groups and were follow-up interviews. The follow-up
interviews were conducted at the Academy of Our Lady of Peace and
each lasted about 20 minutes.
Although we were discussing Spanish-language
programming, the interviews and focus groups were conducted in
English. The data were transcribed by myself or a professional
transcriber. The names of the respondents has been changed.
Results
The results gathered from the focus groups and
interview data indeed reveal that Latina teenagers interpret
television messages through their unique and complex web of
perceptions. The interpretive strategies used by the teenagers were
influenced by their families, religion, culture, peers and previous
media experience. Throughout the data collection process it became
clear that the teenagers actively engage with the messages to
evaluate the characters’ actions.
Respondents were chosen because of their expressed
interest in telenovelas. The focus groups were conducted at private
Catholic high schools. The teens that attend these schools are
generally middle to upper class and have strong religious beliefs.
The homogeneity of the sample must be noted when interpreting the
results. Many of the students were from upper-class Mexican
families.
Telenovelas are a popular form of entertainment for
all Latin American family members especially teenage girls. Most
respondents indicated that they watched telenovelas frequently and
usually in the company of other family members. In addition, many
teenagers stated that they preferred telenovelas to American
programs (although many said they were fans of Dawson’s Creek).
The viewing of telenovelas seems almost habitual.
When I initially asked if the teenagers watched telenovelas, they
answered me in a tone that implied "of course, what a silly
question." Many of the teens explained that they grew up watching
these programs, often in the company of other family members which
in turned encouraged this activity. The participants explained that
they do not usually talk about the stories with their friends
indicating either that it is not worth mentioning because it is
inconsequential or because it is such a part of daily life that it
is redundant to discuss whether or not one saw the telenovela last
night. I believe it is the latter.
The teens based much of their interpretation about
the actions on the telenovelas by looking at what is "right" and
"wrong" according to what had been taught to them by their families
and by their religion -- Catholicism. Most agreed that they were
going to wait until marriage to engage in sexual intercourse, but
they also believed that many teenagers today are sexually active. It
was clear through the discussion with the teenagers that all of them
plan to marry and have a family. It was an assumption that was taken
for granted.
The interpretative strategy based on the perceptions
of right and wrong was frequently voiced by the participants. They
were eager to judge a character’s actions and did so from a
dualistic perspective. Granello (1997) explains that as children
develop, they move from dualistic to multiplistic to relativistic
thinking. Teenagers who are still in the dualistic stage see things
as black or white. As they develop, they learn that issues become
more complex. Therefore, because of their developmental stage (most
were fourteen), the teens tended to dichotomize issues and without
considering possible extenuating circumstances for a character’s
action. For example, Barbara, a character on Tres Mujeres, had an
adulterous affair; the teenagers judged this behavior as "wrong"
based on their own value system. By acknowledging and judging some
characters’ actions as "wrong," the teens tended to reinforce their
own idea of what is "right" and reinforced their desire to be
"good." For these teens, viewing characters engaging in premarital
sex or other sexual activity did not influence them to imitate the
behavior, but rather to condemn it, reaffirming their own values.
This interpretative strategy is consistent with Fingerson’s (1999)
findings that indicated that girls interpret televised messages from
within a certain moral framework.
When first asked if they thought there was too much
sex on telenovelas some nodded yes, but they viewed the portrayal of
sexual interactions as relevant to the stories and somewhat
realistic. Although, not overtly stated, they agreed that many
people in "real life" engage in the type of sexual activity
depicted, emphasizing their own personal lack of experience with
which to compare the representations.
The focus group and interview participants were
asked with whom they usually watch telenovelas to established the
context of viewing. The respondents indicated that they usually
watch telenovelas with other family members or it was other family
members who first introduced them to the programs. The teens
sometimes poked fun at older generations for getting "too into" the
telenovelas because they consider themselves savvy media consumers.
Marta: My mom.... I started watching because of
her.
Patricia: At first it was just my sister and my
mom and when I got a little older, about 12, my [older] brother
started watching and then my father started when I was about 16.
Sofía: My mom, my aunts, when my grandparents
come over, they watch it...My grandmother is really involved with
it, sometimes I don’t understand it because it is so unrealistic.
Victoria: My mom and my sister and I watch them.
It is funny how we can get hooked on something like that.
These responses are consistent with the concept of
familialism discussed by Marín and Marín (1991). It is clear that
the viewing experience includes family, which is central to the
Latin American experience.
Throughout the discussions about the influences
telenovelas have on the viewing audience, many respondents were
eager to talk about the potential effects on other teenagers and
especially younger audiences.
Sofía: I think it is bad for younger kids who
don’t see the difference about what the ladies in the novelas are
portraying. They are very sophisticated but they tell lies to get
their way and kids might think that they should lie to get their
way.
Sylvia: They are very susceptible...Little kids
shouldn’t watch it because they get some bad ideas from it because
they are always taking things in.
Alexa: Maybe if little kids watch them they may
get the wrong idea.
In addition to the general negative influences on
younger audiences, the respondents were concerned about specific
character’s actions. They expressed concern about showing characters
engaging in activities that were not consistent with their values.
One girl had this to say:
Alexa: For example, the one who got cheated on
by the girl. His friends helped him out and bought him drink and
brought him to a club and they found him a girl. And that is what a
person might think after they have been cheated on -- they are going
to go out with their friends to meet somebody new. They are going to
get some kind of example from them.
Referring to showing a character drinking alcohol,
she stated that some viewers might believe that alcohol is
necessarily coupled with sexual activity.
Alexa: In a way it is a bad thing and in a way
it is just normal because you are either going to get an example of
it from commercials or real life but it is wrong because people are
getting a bad example. His friends gave him something to drink and
he found some girl in the club and now he was going to have an
affair [one night stand] with her.
In reference to the same scene...
Alexa: Then people will think that it is normal
to sleep with the person the first time and it is not right. Well it
depends on what kind of a person you are and your morals but I don’t
think it is right...the first time you see it you may think they are
not a ladylike kind of girl, but after you see it, it becomes
common.
Further, the participant continued to discuss other
potential effects of viewing telenovelas. Here she discusses a
positive outcome of including the negative consequences of unwanted
pregnancy.
Alexa: It is good [to show] because it shows you
how it will affect you...They [audience] might realize how much it
really is -- It is not just having sex, there is a risk of ruining
your life. They might adapt it [the example] to their own style of
life. They learn from it. For example, some teenage girls might
learn that is what happens [getting pregnant] and they might say
well that character was dumb because she didn’t use protection and
they might realize they should.
Alexa’s common sense is consistent with what social
learning theory explains is likely to happen. Also, within the
social learning perspective, another participant explains the
benefit of positive portrayals of women.
Ana: At first they showed them [women] as
inferior and scared of men and now they take revenge. It is good
that they are not so inferior anymore.
Ana is cautious, however, of showing women using
their sexuality rather than their mind to get what they want.
Ana: Sometimes the girl offers to sleep with
guys and she said it openly, ‘oh yeah I sleep around with rich men,
that is how I got to where I am.’ She just says it like normal...[it
sends a bad message] because you shouldn’t do that.
Many of the teens explained that because of their
strong moral upbringing, they were not susceptible to the influences
of televised messages. They also were sure they were personally at a
place where they felt "grown up" and able to protect themselves from
television.
Sylvia: No, because in Mexico we are more moral
and we are really into religion. So we are watching telenovelas
because we like to watch them, I don’t get ideas from watching them.
I am going to have sex on my honeymoon.
Marta: In Mexico, the family is very united, I
am very close to my parents, I can tell them anything.
Elena: Once you have lived your teenage years
and you have seen a lot of things so you are not as susceptible [to
TV’s influence].
The teenage respondents stated that they enjoyed
watching telenovelas that feature main characters who are teens.
This is consistent with Josephson (1995), whose research concludes
that adolescents prefer to watch programs that feature their age
group. They explained that they can relate to the problems the teens
face in the programs. Again, looking to social learning theory, the
teenagers responses related to the propositions that the theory
makes. The teens identify with characters that are most like them.
Sofía: There is always a caring friend who gives
advice and I think that most of us have done this in one way or
another before...sometimes its hard [to identify with characters]
because they start off good, but then they go off into the wrong
direction.
Monica: I like [stories] with teenagers, I think
it’s better because you can relate to them more instead of adults.
[I like it] when they deal with all sorts of problems like drugs and
how to deal with it or family struggles.
Liza: There is a new one, it’s all about
teenagers... It’s kind of cool because you can see all the different
problems teenagers have...and how you can solve them....In the 1990s
there are a lot of problems with drugs. A lot of teenagers are
smoking, a lot of teenagers are drinking, a lot of teenagers are
doing drugs, they are doing the hard stuff. We are the future of
this country...It is true [that teens learn from TV] because when
you have a problem you don’t want to accept that you are the only
one having that problem and you don’t want to accept that because
you think people will look weird at you or something but it’s true.
In showing them in the telenovelas they can see that they are not
the only ones having those problems that they can get help, that
there is a solution for their problems...like getting pregnant or
doing drugs.
The participants explained that they thought it was
a good idea to show potential consequences of sexual interactions
when dealing with this topic.
Patricia: They just talked about it [a
character’s abortion] and they showed how it was not really accepted
at all, especially in Mexican cultures. The majority are Catholic
and the culture teaches that kids are always human.
Liza: In a telenovela, this girl got pregnant
because they had unprotected sex. She told her parents and then her
dad was against her and her mom was with her the whole time but
because her dad was neglecting her ran away. Then she had her baby
in a place where they care for you while you’re pregnant but then
the day your child is born they give it up for adoption.
Many stories have to do with lover’s infidelity and
the result of cheating on the relationship. The teenagers noticed
the frequency of these actions and discussed some of the potential
problems with portraying adulterous affairs.
Sylvia: The oldest daughter, she was married and
has two children and she cheated on her husband but he also had an
affair, so now she is with the guy that she had an affair with and
he is the husband’s cousin.
Sofía: The way I see it is they cheat on each
other, the way they [producers] put it, it is okay to have affairs
and cheating on your wife is right and lying and hiding it makes it
seem like it is right...
Isabel: It also shows that you can’t trust
people. All the guys are real jerks and they cheat on people and in
real life it is not like that. Some people are like that but you
can’t look and say everyone is like that.
Alexa: Whenever they are cheating on somebody
and they show that they are cheating on somebody and the viewer
notices it then the other character won’t notice it...[In real life]
people are much smarter...[On the telenovelas] they broke up. [In
real life] I think that girls don’t break up with boys, but the boys
do break up with the girls because it is more often that your see
the boy cheating on the girls than the girl cheating on the boy.
One participant thought the stories about adultery
were reflective of real life. This interpretation by Liza may be
because of her own experiences, although I did not ask who she knew
who had dealt with adultery.
Liza: It is a thing that happens every day
because we know people are cheating on their wives or girlfriends or
the women are cheating on their husbands or boyfriends. They are
putting it into the novelas because first they cheat and then they
get back together, [but] that is not the way it happens in real
life...that is why you have to open your eyes.
Although, the participants revealed that they
understood that the producers had to keep the viewers interested by
having the characters constantly changing partners. They stated that
indeed many married couples do have affairs and they see it as a
common reason for divorce in real life.
The Latina teens agreed that they like the Mexican
telenovelas better than American soap operas. Maybe this is because
they do watch in a familial setting and the telenovela is preferred,
especially for Mexican-Americans new to this country and for those
who reside in Tijuana, but commute to San Diego schools.
Isabel: I think that I like the novelas better
than the English ones because they are so long. I like how the
novelas end, you get a new plot and story line.
Sofía: I think that the telenovelas show a
better perspective on life. The English ones are more foul mouthed
and unfair with marriages, it shows the wrong point of view. When I
see English soap operas they are totally false, they make life seem
so easy. They show that the best way to live life is to have money
and with the telenovelas they show poverty and the poor who are
fighting their way through to lead a successful life.
Mina: Better because it ends, American ones just
go on and on.
María: American ones, I’ve noticed you can spend
watching a week of a show and it can be a day. They are really long.
The teenagers are actively engaged in decoding the
messages in the telenovelas. They use their own social lens to view
these programs. Nevertheless, the potential negative effects of
these programs cannot be dismissed or overlooked because the teens
are "active." It is necessary to continue to think about the
responses the teens have to the programs so that more realistic
portrayals of teenagers on television can be created. The teenagers
want realistic programming -- shows that deal with the issues they
face in daily life. Although the teenagers did not specifically
state when they turn to telenovelas for information, they expect
other teenagers do receive information about life from television.
It may be that television has answers to questions they may be too
embarrassed to ask.
Conclusion
The data from the focus groups and interviews
indicate that the most significant role that television plays is the
reinforcement of existing perceptions about romantic relationships.
Their own cultural and social perspective informs the interpretive
strategies used by the teenagers. Indeed, the Latina teenagers
derived meaning about sexual information by using their own value
system. The information they have stored about sexual activity comes
from a variety of sources including their families, formal sexual
education in schools, peers, and television. They project all this
information every time they evaluate a character’s behavior.
The stories on the telenovelas provide an
opportunity for the teenagers to articulate their own beliefs about
life since they are eager to judge the characters’ actions as right
vs. wrong or realistic vs. unrealistic. In this sense, television
provides models of certain behaviors and situations that teenagers
anticipate happening in their own lives or as "wrong" and something
they will avoid. For example, when they discussed behaviors that
were contrary to what they believed was right, their statements
reinforced their values rather than changing them. This was
evidenced by Ana’s comment regarding "sleeping around." She
explained that "you shouldn’t do that."
The theme of marriage was something the teenagers
did discuss. Since all of the teenagers saw themselves as getting
married in the future and because of their own personal lack of
experience, they viewed the representations of marriage as fairly
realistic. They tended to believe that adultery was common in
marriage -- a prevalent storyline on the telenovelas -- although
they hoped it would not happen to them. They also agreed that a
scene on Sin Tí, depicting a character’s first time on her wedding
night, was realistic. The teenagers in this sample, perhaps because
of their family life as well as their religion, did have an
idealized version of marriage and losing their virginity. The role
of the telenovela in this instance reinforced this fantasy.
What is particularly important to note is that
unlike previous studies that have assumed that the portrayal of
explicit and frequent sexual activity will influence teenagers to
act in this way, this sample of teenagers reaffirmed their own
values and expressed desire not to engage in premarital sex. While
they deemed some actions as inappropriate for themselves, they did
believe that the representations of some romantic relationships were
representative of other people’s behavior.
The teens sampled were predominantly Catholic with
strong ties to their families. Many of them stated that they did not
plan to engage in sexual activity before marriage so that the
information about birth control methods was not necessary for them,
but they felt strongly that this type of information should be
included for teenagers who choose to engage in premarital sexual
intercourse. One participant, Alexa, made the point that the reality
is that teenagers do have sex and therefore they should know how to
protect themselves. She also stated that entertainment television
was an appropriate venue for this information because teenagers do
indeed view telenovelas and they can learn from what they see.
Although these findings do not support direct
observational learning in line with social learning theory what is
supported are disinhibitory effects (Baran and Davis, 2003). In many
cases the teenagers saw the consequences of sexual behavior as
undesirable. In other words, the characters were "punished" (at
least from their point of view) in the storyline and therefore this
lessened the likelihood of identification and imitation.
Nevertheless, the teenagers in the sample believed that "other"
teenagers may indeed be affected by these images of romantic
relationships. In this instance, the teens may be exhibiting the
third person effect – the idea that the media does not affect
oneself, but it may affect others. It may be that the teenagers
could not be self-reflexive in thinking about the role the images of
romantic or intimate relationships play in creating their
understandings. This should be investigated in a future study.
A limitation of the study is that it only looked at
one particular socio-demographic of Latina teens. It is important to
include other Latina teenagers who are not from the upper to middle
class with strong family and religious ties to reveal is their
viewing experiences are much different. Another limitation, which is
common with focus groups and interviews, is the willingness for the
participants to disclose, in this case, private and potentially
embarrassing information. It is hard to say how much the teenagers
were holding back because of the research setting, but they did seem
eager to express their thoughts.
Each inquiry into understanding the relationship
between television messages and their audiences provides another
piece in a very complex puzzle. This study offers insight into how
cultural context influences a particular interpretive community’s
interpretation of televised images. Teenagers are actively engaged
in deconstructing what they see on television and whether they learn
how to behave or how not to behave telenovelas provide much
information about romantic relationships.
Endnotes
[1] A portion of this paper was presented at
International Communication Association, Acapulco, 2000
References
Bandura, A. (1986). Social Foundations of Thought
and Action: A Social Cognitive Theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice Hall. Inc.
Baran, S. J. and Davis, D.K. (2003). Mass
Communication Theory: Foundations, Ferment, and Future, 3rd Ed.
Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thomson Learning.
Brown, J., White, A.B., Nikopoulou, L. (1993).
Disinterest, Intrigue, Resistance: Early Adolescent Girls’ Use of
Sexual Media Content. In Greenberg, B., Brown, J., and
Buerkel-Rothfuss, N. (eds.) (1993). Media, Sex and the Adolescent.
Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
Brown, J. and Steele, J. (1995). Sex and the Mass
Media. Paper presented at Kaiser Family Foundation and American
Enterprise Institute "Sexuality and American Social Policy" Seminar.
Brown, J. and Steele, J. (1996). Sexuality and the
Mass Media: An Overview. SIECUS Report, 24(4), 3-9.
Buckingham, D. (1998). Doing Them Harm? Children’s
Conceptions of the Negative Effects of Television. in Swan, K.,
Meskill, C. and DeMaio, S. (eds.) (1998). Social Learning from
Broadcast Television. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
Fingerson, L. (1999). Active Viewing: Girls’
Interpretations of Family Television Programs. Journal of
Contemporary Ethnography, 28, 389-418.
Granello, D.H. (1997). Using Beverly Hills, 90210 to
Explore Developmental Issues in Female Adolescents. Youth & Society,
29, 24-54.
Greenberg, B., Brown, J. and Buerkel-Rothfuss, N.
(eds.) (1993). Media, Sex, and the Adolescent. Cresskill, NJ:
Hampton Press, Inc.
Greenberg, B. and Busselle, R. (1994). Quantity and
Quality of Sex in the Soaps. Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic
Media, 29, 519-535.
Greenberg, B. and Busselle, R. (1996a). Soap Operas
and Sexual Activity: A Decade Later. Journal of Communication, 46,
153-160.
Greenberg, B. and Busselle, R. (1996b). What’s Old,
What’s New: Sexuality on the Soaps. SIECUS Report, 24(5), 14-16.
Heintz-Knowles, K., Engstrand, K. and Stern, S.
(1997). More Action Less Talk: Content Anaylsis of Daytime Soap
Operas. Paper presented at the International Communication
Association, Montreal.
Lowry, D.T. and Towles, D.E. (1989). Soap Opera
Portrayals of Sex, Contraception, and Sexually Transmitted Diseases.
Journal of Communication, 39, 76-83.
Marín, G. and Marín, B.V. (1991). Research with
Hispanic Populations. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
McAnany, E. and La Pastina, A. (1994). Telenovela
Audiences: A Review and Methologolgical Crtitque of Latin American
Research. Communication Research, 21(6), 828-849.
McQuail, D. (1994). Mass Communication Theory: An
Introduction, 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Morley, D. (1993). Active Audience Theory: Pendulums
and Pitfalls. Journal of Communication, 43, 13-21.
Nariman, H. (1993). Soap Operas for Social Change:
Toward Methodology for Entertainment-Education Television. Westport,
CA: Praeger Publishers.
Rodriquez, A. (http://www.museum.tv/archives/etv/U/htmlU/univision/univision.htm)
retrieved 4/4/03.
Strasburger, V. (1995). Adolescents and the Media:
Medical and Psychological Impact. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
Publications.
Wartella, E. (1983). Children and Television: The
Development of the Child’s Understanding of the Medium. Mass
Communciation Review Yearbook, No. 1, 516-538.
Univision Press Packet, 1999.
|