|
Article No. 1
Impact and Implications of New
Information Technology
on Middle Eastern Youth
Mahboub E. Hashem
American University of
Sharjah, U. A. E.
Abstract
This paper presents and reflects upon
Middle Eastern youth’s use of new information technology (IT) and
the implications of that use. Several key problems and great
prospects related to that use will be identified. Middle Eastern
youth were found to be fond of their IT use mostly because of their
ability to access all sorts of information and communicate with the
outside world, including friends and family members abroad. To those
youth, while IT is building bridges between them and distant others,
it is also building ever stronger walls between them and close
individuals, including family members, relatives, and neighbors at
the same time. Those youth admit that they surround themselves with
IT tools while paying little attention to some of their own needs as
well as the needs of others around them. In addition, they are fully
aware that misuse of IT tools and addiction are leading to
destructive behaviors affecting them in major ways. The purpose of
this paper is to address the impact and implications of new IT on
Middle Eastern youth, namely the way they are using these
technologies and the consequences of that use. The instruments used
were short essays and questionnaires which took into account Middle
Eastern sensitive sub-cultural differences among the target
population. While subjects were given ample time to write and submit
their essays, the questionnaires were scheduled and administered on
time by professionals. Reasons for the stated problems and
recommendations to prevent them or deal with them are provided in
the course of this paper. In addition, the paper indicates the need
for a comparative and coherent body of research across cultures
pertaining to the impact and implications of new IT on our youth.
Introduction
New information Technology (IT) is
almost everywhere and has dramatically altered the way we live. As a
result, the role of IT in our daily living is growing rapidly to the
degree that many of us, especially youngsters, have become dependent
on, if not addicted to, our mobile phones and personal computers
(PCs), which now constitute the principal tools for our interaction,
research, and learning. As is the case anywhere in the world, both
of these tools have become valued elements of life in the Middle
Eastern region merely because they opened many doors to youth and
allowed them to interact freely and markedly unlike at any other
time in history. Although these tools and the related programs they
provide have had a rather late start in that region, nevertheless
most, if not all, Middle Eastern States allow public access to them
these days. Hence, cyber communication has become as normal and
fashionable as any other human activity. This has become so due to
IT tools which allow their users to discover the never-ending and
most up-to-date information available about almost anyone or
anything worldwide. As Amrohvi (2008, p. 11) noted when she talked
about the digital world and computers, “what started out as a
computing tool used by scientists and in business is now a must have
tool for all.” The same thing can be said about mobile phones, they
are “must haves” for almost everyone these days.
Like tsunami waves, college and
university campuses have been hit by new generations of youth coming
from high schools with quite a decent knowledge about IT and how to
use its tools, especially cellular phones and computers. These youth
have been referred to as the Echo Boomers, Millennial, the Net
Generation, etc. The expectations, attitudes, and fluency with new
IT of this generation have been beyond belief. Hence, dealing with
these youth has been a challenge for educators, parents, and
governments alike, especially in a region similar to the Middle East
wherein public mingling between the genders is generally
discouraged, many schools are segregated, and certain unclean
behaviors or foul language are mostly edited out of the mass media.
(Galal, 2002; Tubaishat et all, 2006; Wheeler, 2003)
The Middle East is well known as a
region for some of the most autocratic and least democratic
political systems existing worldwide. As such, Middle Eastern youth
have to find creative ways to deal with or bypass their parents’
control as well as their governments’ cyber patrol concerning their
media use or activities. While any technology can be put to good or
bad use, depending on the user, many parents have bought their kids
cellular phones and PCs so they may use them appropriately and
effectively, mainly for learning purposes as well as knowing where
they are at any time and come to their help if they need it.
However, kids are not just using these IT tools for calling or
learning only but for other purposes too. As some of the youth have
stated, “whenever they close doors, we find windows to get in and do
what we want.” Therefore, despite incessant efforts by parents and
governments, many Middle Eastern youth have been capable of using
their cellular phones and computers for multiple purposes in an
effort to search out materials they need or are interested in
without major challenges.
Purpose
The purpose of this
paper is to address the impact and implications of new IT on Middle
Eastern youth, namely the way they are using these technologies and
the consequences of that use.
Literature review
For the past several decades, the Middle
Eastern youth population has been increasing explosively,
particularly in the Arabian Gulf region, due to complicated reasons
such as religious beliefs, traditions, ineffective birth control
methods, etc. This is visible in urban or heavily populated areas
and is creating social, economic, and cultural problems which are
affecting young people studies, job opportunities, training, health,
life-styles, and well-being (Gleeson & Sipe, 2006). This confirms
what Robertson (1995) stated more than a decade ago with regard to
positive and negative global and technological developments and
their clear influences upon generations everywhere. While several
Middle Eastern societies have been benefiting from technological
advancements and so are their youth, many others have been suffering
due to youth unemployment and lack of economic prosperity. These
important factors and others have led many youngsters to migrate
whenever possible, become underemployed, or get involved in awkward
behaviors such as committing crimes, drinking excessively, and
becoming addicted to bizarre substances, which eventually result in
unavoidable practices of violence (United Nations, 2005a & b;
Yigitcanlar & Baum, 2006).
The rapid growth and dissemination of
new IT have helped in analyzing and understanding the great
opportunities as well as the challenges Middle Eastern youth are
experiencing. While IT offers new opportunities to Middle Eastern
youth for learning, job training, and skill development; it also
creates many challenges that deserve close attention by adults
around them. One of the major challenges facing Middle Eastern youth
is the possibility of accessing IT tools and knowing how to use
them. In other words, it is the gap between the “haves” and
“have-nots.” Unlike the case in developed nations, many Middle
Eastern developing countries lack in acquiring broad access to new
IT tools and, as a result, cannot provide these tools to their
youth, become vulnerable to global market changes, and, then,
youth’s unemployment or migration gets into high gear. In fact, IT
access and usage differ mainly because of social status, and not due
to personal preferences, and because many crucial social and
economic benefits can accrue from greater access and usage of IT.
Such IT disparities represent a serious divide, not just between
developed and developing nations, but also between various segments
within each Middle Eastern society. Therefore, impartial access to
information, knowledge, and education has become sine-qua-non to the
emerging global knowledge economy. IT tools have also become
necessary to narrow the knowledge gaps between developed and
developing countries as well as among the “haves” and “have-nots”
within every society. This requires edging in the areas of
information exchange, intellectual freedom, and online education. IT
tools are potent in making that edging toward contributing to
development and prosperity. In addition, the production and
continuous use of IT have actually become the driving forces behind
transforming modern societies. As such, they have radically
restructured the labor market and the criteria for employability
have become much higher and requiring more advanced skills, a fact
which youth of developing nations cannot keep-up with (Haddon, 2001;
Walsh et al., 2001; Kozma et al., 2004).
Research findings suggest that many of
those developing nations which undergo those high levels of
unemployment and migration are in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA;
25.6%). Hence, youth in these countries have to face many challenges
in education and training which are supposed to assure them some of
the mostly needed and highly requested skills by the labor market.
As a result, the move from high school to work has never been easy
for most youths who end up either unemployed or underemployed
(United Nations, 2005a & b; Yigitcanlar & Baum, 2006).
With colossal social intricacy, IT,
especially the Internet, has not only had universal positive impact
on contemporary societies, but also has caused various societal
concerns about privacy, security, pornography, digital divide, Cyber
crime, virtual community, intellectual property right, etc. As Katz
and Rice (2002) mentioned, IT seems another double-edge weapon that
has intense positive and negative social consequences. It unites
huge technical and social complexities and this distinctive blend
makes youth’s understanding of IT both significant and challenging.
There are four major uses of IT namely,
seeking information for the purpose of teaching and learning;
communication; entertainment; and shopping (e-commerce). The first
line of inquiry pointed out to the existence of a relationship
between IT use and academic performance, even though causal
relationships have been hard to ascertain (Blanton et al., 1997;
Cole, 1996; Roschelle et al., 2000; & Subrahmanyam et al., 2001).
However, the fact remains that IT, especially the Internet, has
become crucial source of research and educational tool in almost all
institutions around the globe. Its benefits seem to outweigh its
negatives. For instance, a special section of Developmental
Psychology (Greenfield & Yan, 2006), which was published by the
American Psychological Association (APA), included six empirical
articles showcasing various aspects of child and adolescent
development in this virtual world while living in the real world.
These articles discussed three major themes (communication on the
Internet; cognitive development, academic achievement, and the
Internet; and adolescents in a globalized Internet world). They
mostly affirmed that Internet use involves both “pros and cons for
children and adolescents.” Some of their findings suggest that
online interactions supply vital support for lonely adolescents.
However, these online panels may lead to lethal actions such as
self-injurious practices by the same adolescents. In addition, some
of these articles asserted that the Internet can also be a good
educational tool for far-away populations. Students who used the
Internet more had higher test scores in reading and higher grade
point averages (GPAs) than those who used the Internet less. For
instance, Borzekowski, Fobil, and Asante (2006) looked at “Ghanaian
teens’ use of the Internet for health information.” They found that
“youth reported great interest, high levels of efficacy, and
positive perceptions of online health information.” (p. 450)
Smith & Winking-Diaz (2004) looked at
increasing students’ activity in an on-line course, due to advances
in networking technologies, the World Wide Web, and the Internet
which have had a great influence on teaching and learning in higher
education. Students and teachers, especially at the college or
university level, have been functioning in a high-tech and
high-touch mediated learning environment. Hence, they have been
using a wide range of IT tools to interact, work cooperatively, and
share a variety of resources; these tools have been providing them
with whatever they need at anytime and anywhere. Galabov (2001)
studied the Internet and the Arab culture, which, presumably, “has
been reaping all the benefits the Internet has to offer.” (p. 1) He
argues that the Internet has become an important component of life
in the Middle East, for it allows people of the region, particularly
women, to communicate freely, access information quickly and
inexpensively. Adopting the new IT has been aiming at raising the
quality of lifestyle and “to help women become more competitive,
well-educated, and professional partners in society.” (p. 2)
Tubaishat et al. (2006) investigated ICT
experiences in two different Middle Eastern universities. Their
survey results show that adoption of new technology has improved
students’ motivation, level of confidence, communication and
technical skills, collaboration, and sense of independence. They
specifically stated that “these improvements would not have been
possible without technology in a gender-segregated society.” (p.
667). Other researchers identified primary use of IT for school work
or projects and secondary use for communication with family members,
friends, and acquaintances through e-mail, instant messaging, and
chat rooms (Turow, 1999; Turow & Nir, 2000; Valkenburg & Soeters,
2001; Gross, 2004). This second use leads us to the next section of
discussion.
The second major line of research
consists of using IT for communication. Researchers and
practitioners admit that the use of IT for interacting with others
is not very recent but goes back decades in time when it was
developed and used for military purposes (Hardey, 2002). In fact,
for the past 10-15 years, researchers have looked at the effect of
IT, especially the Internet, over social life, cultural norms,
studying or learning, dating, and a host of other issues. For
instance, Gross (2004) found that communication was the number one
use of the Internet for the upper-middle-class adolescents. The
degree to which the Internet was used for communication relied on
the number of acquaintances, family members, and friends online.
Other researchers emphasized that certain people used the Internet
to find particular information before initiating an interaction of
some kind. For instance, Hardey (2002) examined the embodiment and
identity through the Internet. He pointed out how dating websites
hold profiles, personal, and demographic information concerning
those looking for partners, just like newspapers’ personal columns.
This way, members of the opposite sex may surf throughout those
profiles and initiate an on-line contact with whoever is deemed
appropriate and have a good potential to build a relationship with.
Some researchers compared cyber
communication to face-to-face interactions; looked at causes and
consequences of social interaction on the Internet; discussed cyber
relationship formation, and considered certain observations and
implications for Internet sex addictions. Their findings revealed
that the primary use of home PCs was for social interaction rather
than for anything else, on-line communication was the easiest or
most accessible, and, due to secrecy or anonymity, both sexes were
encouraged to share some aspects of their personality that they may
not reveal otherwise and, particularly, off-line. In addition, they
found some similarities between these two types of communication,
especially concerning electronic mail, chat rooms, face-book, and
instant messaging. While face-to-face communication consumes a lot
of time to build trust and intimacy, on-line interaction provides
anonymity and permits communicators to self-disclose and become
intimate much sooner than in the other type. Therefore, it was
considered the most trouble-free, most unique, and most accessible
way to meet potential partners. (McKenna et al., 2002; Grffiths,
2001)
In a similar vein, Galal (2002) studied
on-line dating in Egypt. She found that more than half of the
respondents from both sexes reported being involved in on-line
dating; although for different reasons. She stated that males’ main
reason for resorting to cyber-relationships was lack of
self-confidence stemming from their inability to initiate off-line
romantic relationships, peer pressure, and gender expectations.
However, females were found to get involved in on-line relationships
mainly because they are pressured by social norms which do not
permit the formation of relationships with the opposite sex for
females. Therefore, they resort to on-line relationships in an
effort not to risk social sanctions because on-line relationships
are supposedly anonymous.
Many researchers looked at how excessive
use of the Internet can lead to addiction and some of its potential
positive and negative effects. Hence, findings revealed that
socializing through the Internet is convenient, provides some escape
and anonymity. It may also improve users’ mental well-being; reduce
or alleviate their anxiety, loneliness, and depression. In addition,
it can boost their social support, self-esteem, and cultivate their
empathy, zest, empowerment, and trust in others (Griffiths, 2001;
McKenna, 2002; Silverman, 2001; Weiser, 2001; Shaw, 2002; Peled,
2000; Sanders, 2000; Grohol, 2005; Shier, 2005; Young, 2001). For
instance, Wheeler (2001 & 2003) studied the Internet and public
culture as well as youth subculture in Kuwait. She found that more
females than males reported using the Internet for leisure and
meeting the opposite sex and, as a result, a large number of on-line
couples end up meeting in person as potential partners for long-term
relationships. Since Kuwait is a traditional and conservative small
country which does not encourage the mixing of the two genders, the
Internet was found to provide Kuwaiti youth with a way to twist the
rules with minimal danger of publicity.
Some researchers focused on the negative
side of Internet addiction. Thus, while the Internet offers youth
the opportunity to instantaneously seek information using a variety
of search engines; interact with others and, virtually, meet with
members of the opposite sex through a variety of chat programs (ICR,
ICQ, MSN, My-Space, Sitcom, Face-book, etc.); the addiction to it
through spending prolonged periods of time over its IT programs
leads to wasting much valuable time, building shallow and harmful
relationships, and, eventually, causing rather than alleviating,
users’ depression, loneliness, social isolation, and withdrawal
among other things, particularly to our youth (Peled, 2000;
Griffiths, 2001; & Sanders, 2000).
Lynch (2007) looked at using the
Internet for communicating with others about a variety of topics,
including political issues. Hence, he was one of those who
introduced the phenomenon of blogging to the Arab public. He stated
that using the Internet and blogging (an alternative way of telling
the news) are growing fast among youth in certain Arab countries.
Blogs are found to allow youth to get engaged in politics and escape
the red lines imposed by most Middle Eastern governments. As such,
blogs seem to chip away at the sheltered Arab structures in an
effort to bring in new voices and build new and warm relationships
among otherwise distant Arab youth; or perhaps build such
relationships across the Arab-Western divide. He also assumed that
blogs are breaking off the encrusted structures of the Arab
authorities, bringing in new voices that had no outlet in the past,
and testing the norms or expectations prevailing over the Arab
public political discourse. Arab political blogs have the potential
to hold the prospect of a new Arab public field that may reform the
quality of politics. This wave of Arab blogging has been dominated
early on by young bloggers who are technologically oriented,
politically unengaged, and literally using English as a medium for
their blogs. However, this is moving slowly to more politically
engaged bloggers who dare to write in Arabic. The main purpose of
this new type of media use (blogging) is to free arrested political
activists through running campaigns, linking exchanges online,
showing high resolution photos or embedded videos of protests, and
the like.
The remaining two types of IT use,
shopping and entertainment, did not receive as much attention by
researchers as the first two (communication and searching for
information). Many high school and university students have been
downloading music through their use of the Internet and copying
whatever they like on CDs. Some of those students made good money of
selling certain CDs while others have been using their laptops to
substitute for all other media namely, radios, televisions, videos,
newspapers, magazines, periodicals, and even books. This fact led
the music industry, particularly, Napster Music Services to file law
suits against whoever does this and asked that some regulation is
put into place. The
parameters of music in the USA have been increasing significantly
with the advancements of such companies like Napster and the
technology to burn or copy CDs. In addition, bands such as Metallica
have been leading the fight to eliminate the piracy of copyrighted
music as well. However, no matter what kind of regulations or
parameters are imposed, youth continue to illegally copy CDs and
listen to whatever kind of music available for downloading.
As
noted by this review of literature, the spiraling advance in IT has
led to major changes in telecommunication practices amongst Middle
Eastern people, especially their youth. Those practices have
presented new political, cultural, and moral predicaments and
prospects which have never had such a pattern in the history of that
region. In such rapidly changing environment, communication plays a
much more important role today than ever before in the Middle East.
Hence, Middle Easterners, especially their youngsters, are actively
using IT resources for multiple purposes. In addition, their IT
resources have become an essential part of their lifestyle and
social assets. Thus, developing interpersonal, business, and
relational skills become very critical for their productivity and
advancement in the information age. As such, the
use of IT to facilitate their communication, e-commerce, learning,
and relationship building becomes of utmost importance in the Middle
Eastern region.
In sum, most of the reviewed studies
found that new IT, the Internet and mobile phones in particular,
have more positive than negative effects on Middle Eastern youth.
In fact, they have been amazing phenomena since their introduction
to the Middle Eastern societies wherein both genders do not have
many opportunities to meet face-to-face without being chaperoned by
someone in many of those societies. They are thought to have
provided more benefits than vices to youth in that region. Although
some argue that Internet and mobile-based communications are similar
to face-to-face interactions with only minor differences pertaining
to accessibility, anonymity, decreasing depression or loneliness,
and fear of rejection (Griffiths, 2001; McKenna, 2002; Shaw, 2002;
Silverman, 2001); the author of this paper still argues that
face-to-face interaction remains the most reliable and efficient
channel of communication, due to many more nonverbal cues and
immediate feedback. The argument is that Internet and mobile-based
communications may become more efficient and reliable after the
initial face-to-face interaction or meeting takes place. Hence, they
become an integral part of or complementary component to
face-to-face initial contact. How does this apply to Middle Eastern
youth who are mostly afraid to meet face- to-face, due to cultural
restrictions and how did they benefit from their IT? Do they use IT
to communicate more than to search for information, shop, or get
entertained?
This IT use by Middle Eastern youth was
guided by the theoretical framework of Uses and Gratification for
the purpose of helping us analyze and understand that particular
use. Uses and Gratification Theory presumes that people are in
control, active, and goal-directed, in contrast to passively
receiving media messages. Hence, people take the initiative to link
gratification needs with their media choices and uses, from among
available alternative media sources (Blumler & Katz, 1974;
Papacharissi & Rubin, 2000; Ruggiero, 2000). New IT offers easy
accessibility, anonymity, asynchroneity, demassification,
interactivity, and positivity or non-retaliatory features (Borzekowski
& Rickert, 2001a; Ruggiero, 2000; Suzuki & Calzo, 2004; Williams,
Rice, & Rogers, 1988). Therefore, Uses and Gratification Theory
seems pertinent to studying youth’s use of IT for a variety of
timely needs gratification as it offers a good framework for
examining why Middle Eastern youth turn to these new media types to
communicate, disseminate, and obtain specific kinds of information
as well as to shop and be entertained. Based on existing research
with regard to using IT and the nature of most Middle Eastern
societies, the following hypotheses were formulated:
Hypothesis 1: Middle
Eastern youth will use IT tools more for communication than for
anything else.
Hypothesis 2: Greater
IT use will negatively affect Middle Eastern youth’s personal
communication (face-to-face) or socialization.
Hypothesis 3: Middle
Eastern young females will use IT more than young males for shopping
purposes.
Methodology
Participants
Participating in this study were 225
students of a midsize private university in the Middle Eastern
region. The population of that university comes from about 80
different nations, mostly Middle Eastern countries, which may be
considered a somewhat good representation of the Middle East. 75
participants were males (33%) and 150 were females (67%). Their age
varied “between” 18-24. After participants’ assents were attained, a
15-minute anonymous survey was administered during the academic year
2007-2008. In addition, 45 participants out of the same sample,
agreed to write a short essay (self-report) concerning their use of
IT. Thus, the 225 youth anonymously responded to a 24 question
survey and 45 of them agreed to confidentially self-report on their
use of IT, namely cellular phones and Internet.
Measures
Mobile Phone Use:
Mobile use variable was based on participants’ responses to a
4-point Likert scale to certain survey questions pertaining to the
number of Cellular Phones; duration of use per day; and specificity
of that use.
Internet Use:
Internet use variable was based on participants’ responses to a
4-point Likert scale to a survey questions pertaining to longevity
of Internet use at home, at school, and Internet cafés; number of
e-mail addresses they have; duration of use per day; specificity of
use; etc. Overall, multiple choice questions were asked so
participants could easily designate their responses.
Results and discussion
For this study, 225 Middle Eastern
youth participated in the survey and 45 students of the 225 agreed
to confidentially write a short essay (self-report) concerning their
IT use. Sample characteristics and descriptive statistics for mobile
and Internet use consist of the percentages which are presented in
Tables 1, 2, 3 respectively. Table 1 lists percentages concerning
sample demographics. As shown in Table 1, 33% of the sample were
males and 67% were females. Ages of participants varied between 18
and 24 and a large majority were sophomore and junior.
Hypothesis 1 states that Middle Eastern
youth will use IT tools more for communication than for anything
else. This hypothesis was not confirmed, for the results indicate
that Middle Eastern youth use their IT tools to equally communicate,
seek information, and be entertained, as can be seen in Tables 2 and
3 respectively. Hence, Middle Eastern youth’s use of IT appears to
be almost equally proportioned among the three activities:
communication, entertainment, and searching for information
(personal and/or class assignments). Their IT use for shopping
purposes lagged behind the above mentioned three activities.
As can be seen from Table 2, mobiles
were almost equally used for communication and entertainment
(listening to music and playing games). However, females used their
mobiles more for calling family and friends than for entertainment,
while males used theirs more for entertainment than for calling. As
to time of use per day, Table 2 shows that the large majority of
males and females use their mobiles between 60-300 minutes (1-5
hours per day). This is a lot of time spent using the phone on a
daily basis. There is one interesting finding which concerns the
number of owned mobiles. While all males claimed to have only one
Table
1: Demographics
Sample Characteristics
Characteristics
Total Male Female
(N = 225) (N = 75) (N
= 150)
Gender
Male
(33%) (33%) (67%)
Female
(67%)
Age
19 or Under
(27%)
(33%) (26%)
20-24
(73%)
(67%) (74%)
25-29
(0%)
30-34
(0%)
Educational Level
Freshman
(0%)
(0%) (0%)
Sophomore
(50%)
(52%) (33%)
Junior
(31%) (30%) (33%)
Senior
(19%) (17%) (33%)
Table
2: Mobile Use
Total
Male Female
Descriptive Stats (N =
225) N = 75 (33%) N = 150 (67%)
_____________________________________________________________________
Number of mobiles
1 phone
only
(100%) (54%)
2 phones
only
(0%) (34%)
3 phones only
(0%) (0%)
4 + phones
(0%)
(12%)
Time of use per day
0-60 minutes
(m)
(30%) (22%)
60-120
m
(34%) (26%)
120-300 m
(35%)
(43%)
300 m
+
(1%) (9%)
Specific use
Calling family &
friends
(40%) (60%)
Entertainment
(56%) (40%)
Business
(4%) (0%)
Other (specify)
(0%) (0%)
mobile (100%), 54 percent of females
stated that they own only one, 34 percent declared that they own
two, and 12 percent affirmed that they own more than four mobiles.
This may be due to the fact that females, unlike males, use
different mobiles for different activities in the Middle East (one
mobile to interact with family members, a second mobile to
communicate with friends, a third one for romance, etc.).
Table 3, describes youths’ Internet use.
25 percent of males declared that they have only one e-mail address
and 75 percent have two. When it comes to females, none of them has
only one e-mail address, 96 percent have either two or three (48% &
48%), and only four percent claimed to have four e-mail addresses.
This does not seem a coincidence that females have more mobiles and
more e-mail addresses than males. Middle Eastern female youth appear
to have different and more varied uses for IT than males, may be
because they have more secrets and want to hide certain things from
people around them.
As to Internet access at home and in
school, all sample males and females (100%) claimed to have access
at both, home and school. Both males and females claimed that IT
distracts them from studying (67% - 70%), causes them to sleep less
(33% - 44%), and leads them to rely more on chatting than on
calling. Only 13 percent of female youth affirmed to have used the
Internet more responsibly and, hence, the Internet did not
negatively affect them. When asked to elaborate on Internet effects
on them, many of both males and females claimed to have “less
studying time, less face-to-face interaction with family members and
friends, more chatting with people of same interest or age groups,
less sleeping time because of addiction and losing track of time
using the Internet for chatting and watching movies.”
As to the frequency of Internet use, 67
percent of males and 75 percent of females admitted to being
addicted to the Internet because of their high use of that medium
(4-7 hours a day); 33 percent of males and 44 percent of females
claimed to be moderate users of this medium (1-3 hours a day); and
only four percent of females asserted to be regular users (1-2 hours
a day).
With regard to the question of overall
importance of the Internet for them, 100 percent of males and 74
percent of females stressed that the Internet is very important to
them; and only 26 percent of females emphasized that the Internet is
just important to them. Concerning the question of overall
self-rating of their IT use, only four percent of females claimed to
be beginners; 67 percent of males and 44 percent of females asserted
to be intermediate; and 33 percent of males and 52 percent of
females confirmed to be advanced IT users.
Hypothesis 2 states that IT use will
negatively affect Middle Eastern youth’s personal communication
(face-to-face) and socialization. This hypothesis was confirmed.
Almost all 45 participants who self-reported on their IT use as well
as a large percentage of respondents (males and females) who
participated in the survey, when asked to elaborate on IT effect,
have indicated that their IT use have affected their studying,
sleeping, and socialization or face-to-face communication. While
several participants claimed to have been positively affected due to
their wise and responsible use of their IT tools, a large percentage
of them pointed out to the negative effects their IT use has had on
them.
Table
3: Internet Use
Total Male
Female
Descriptive Stats (N = 225) N = 75
(33%) N = 150 (67%)
NO of e-mail addresses
Only
one
(25%) (0%)
Two
(75%) (48%)
Three
(0%) (48%)
Four or more
(0%) (4%)
Internet Access
Home
(100%) (100%)
School
(100%) (100%)
Types of Internet Use
E-mailing
(100%) (100%)
Searching for
information (100%)
(100%)
Chatting
(67%) (87%)
Face-book
(100%) (78%)
Entertainment (Music &
Games) (100%) (95%)
Shopping
(67%) (20%)
Affected Activities
Distraction from
studying
(67%) (70%)
Sleeping much
less
(33%) (44%)
Chatting more & calling
less (67%) (48%)
Responsible use/no
effect
(0%) (13%)
Frequency of Internet Use
Addiction/High (4-7 hours a
day) (67%) (75%)
Moderate (1-3 hours a day)
(33%) (44%)
Regular (1-2 hours a
day) (0%) (4%)
Infrequent use (few times a
week) (0%) (0%)
Overall Importance of Internet
Very
important
(100%) (74%)
Important
(0%) (26%)
Somewhat
important
(0%) (0%)
Not
important
(0%) (0%)
Overall Self-Rate of IT Use
Beginner
(0%)
(4%)
Intermediate
(67%) (44%)
Advanced
(33%) (52%)
Some of the typical positive and
negative statements concerning participants’ IT use are as follows:
Positive
statements
“Sharing thoughts and helping spread a
good word online such as, the blood drive to save others’ lives…;
the Internet is very useful when it comes to academic work; I use it
moderately; things like Facebook and chatting are a waste of time…;
although I use the Internet often, but I use it wisely without it
becoming a distraction. I usually have a purpose for using it and I
don’t just access it for no reason in mind; I can reach all
information I want/need; I interact with people from all over the
world using the Internet; the Internet helps me in my research work
for the university; I find it easier to chat rather than calling; I
cannot spend a day without using my mobile and checking all my
Internet accounts; both of these tools have become like bread and
butter for me;” etc.
Negative
statements
“ Due to my IT use, I have much less
face-to-face interactions and socialization with family and friends,
instead I have more chatting with people of the same interests or
age group; chatting a lot with someone prevents me from seeing
others face-to-face or talking to them when I see them; there is no
need to meet people face-to-face, which is bad; I have no social
life and I am dependent on Net friends; I don’t have time for my
social life as I am spending too much time in front of my laptop or
mobile; when working on the Internet, I don’t feel that time is
passing so I end up sleeping very late; I lose track on the Net and
therefore sleep much later than I should; because of the Internet or
mobile, I concentrate less on studying, become less and less social,
and feel tired all the time; Internet and mobile take-up the time I
should spend studying; I spend much less time communicating
face-to-face with others especially with family; I go on Facebook,
download music, or browse the Net instead of giving my full
attention to my studies or communicating face-to-face with others; I
stay up chatting to my friends instead of sleeping; the Internet has
made me socialize less; I choose to interact more through chatting
rather than talking in person or face-to-face; using the Internet at
home pulls me away from interacting with my family members;” etc.
Concluding
remarks
As the results indicate, this survey and
self-reporting research helped in discovering Middle Eastern Youth’s
descriptions of how they feel about the new information technology,
themselves and their behaviors concerning the use of that technology
as well as their understanding of the results of that use. While
they appreciate this technology and admit that they cannot live
without it anymore because it became necessary and very beneficial
to them, they can also perceive and feel its danger, especially what
has been called “mobile and/or Internet addiction disorder.”
However, this addiction does not seem very different from any other
one people may have with regard to watching too much TV, reading too
many stories and articles, working too many hours, or drinking
excessively. Addiction to anything seems a way of escaping reality
or busying ourselves with things that may help us forget certain
real problems and fill certain void in our lives. Therefore, the new
information technology is here to stay and we better get used to it.
It should not be seen as a foe just because many of us grow to be
dependent on it. It provides numerous essential benefits. It is
prompt, economical, expedient, and educational. The only thing we
need to be alert to is to wisely use it with some kind of
self-control so it does not disrupt our daily schedules, cause us to
neglect our duties towards important relationships or
responsibilities, or make our lives miserable. Finally, there
appears to be a pressing need for more comparative and coherent body
of research across cultures pertaining to the impact and
implications of new IT on our youth everywhere so they and we may be
enlightened about and guided by the use of that technology.
References
Amrohvi, I. A.
(Sunday, May 11, 2008, p. 11). Gulf news-Notes. Digital
World: Online technology is
virtually improving our lives.
Blanton, W.. E.,
Moorman, G. B., Hayes, B. A., & Warner, M. L. (1997). Effects of
participation
in the Fifth Dimension on Far Transfer. Journal of Educational
Computing Research, 16,
371-396.
Blumler, J. G., &
Katz, E. (1974). The uses of mass communications: Current
perspectives on
gratifications research. Bevely Hills, CA: Sage.
Borzekowski, D. L.
G., & Ricckert, V. I. (2001a). Adolescents, the Internet, and
health: Issues of
access and content. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 22,
49-59.
Borzekowski, D. L.
G. & Fobil, J. N., & Asante, K. O. (2006). Online access by
adolescents in Accra:
Ghanaian teens’ use of the Internet for health information, 42(3),
450-458.
Cole, M. (1996).
Cultural psychology: A once and future discipline. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard
University Press.
Galabov, M. (2001).
Internet and the Arab culture. Al-Shindagah: Retrieved 4/15/2008
from
http://www.alshindagah.com/july2001/internet_and_the_arab_culture.html
Galal, I. (2002).
On-line dating in Egypt. Retrieved 4/10/2008 from:
http://lass.calumet.purdue.edu/cca/gmj/oldsitebackup/submitteddocuments/archivedpape
Gleeson, B. and
Sipe, N. (2006). Creating child friendly cities: Reinstating kids in
the city (Eds.).
Rutledge: New York.
Greenfield, P. &
Yan, Z. (2006). Children, adolescents, and the Internet: A new field
of inquiry in
Developmental Psychology. Developmental Psychology, 42(3), 391-394.
Griffiths, M.
(2001). Observations and implications for Internet sex addiction.
Journal of Sex Research,
38 (4).
Grohol, J. M.
(2005). Internet addiction guide. Retrieved on 6/24/2008 from
http://psychcentral.com/netaddiction/
Gross, E. F.
(2004). Adolescent Internet use: What we expect, what teens report.
Journal of Applied
Developmental Psychology, 25, 633-649.
Haddon, L. (2001).
Social exclusion and information and communication technologies. New
Media and
Society, 2(4): 387-406.
Hardey, M. (2002).
Life beyond the screen: Embodiment and identity through the
Internet. The
Sociological Review, 50(4): 570-585.
International Labor
Organization (2005). Youth, education, and employment. United
Nations Economic
Commission for Africa. UN Publication: New York.
Katz, J. E., &
Rice, R. E. (2002). Social consequences of Internet use: Access,
involvement, and
interaction. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Kozma, R., McGhee,
R., Quellmalz, E., & Zalles, D. (2004). Closing the digital divide: Evaluation of
the World Links program. International Journal of Educational
Development,24: 361-381.
Lynch, M. (2007).
Blogging the new Arab public: Arab blogs’ political influence will
grow. World
Politics Review, retrieved 4/15/2008 from:
http://www.worldpoliticsreview.com/article.aspx?id=694
McKenna, K. et al.
(2002). Relationship formation on the Internet: What’s the big
attraction?Journal of
Social Issues, 58 (1): 9-31.
Papacharissi, Z., &
Rubin, A. M. (2000). Predictors of Internet use. Journal of
Broadcasting and Electronic
Media, 44, 175-196.
Peled, A. (2000).
Internet myths in the Levant. Middle East Quarterly,
September: 41-45.
Robertson, J.
(1995). Electronics, environment and employment: Harnessing private
gain to the common
good. Futures, 27 (5): 487-504.
Roschelle, J. M.,
Pea, R. D., Hoadley, C. M., Gordon, D. N., & Means, B. M. (2000). Changing how
and what children learn in school with computer-based technologies.
Children and
Computer Technology, 10(2), Fall/Winter, 76-101. Retrieved July 8,
2008, from
http://www.futureofchildren.org
Ruggiero, T. E.
(2000). Uses and gratifications theory in the 21st
century. Mass Communication
and Society, 3, 3-37.
Sanders, C. et al.
(2000). The relationship of Internet use to depression and social
isolation among
adolescents. Adolescence, 35 (138): 237-243.
Shaw, L. et al.
(2002). In defense of the Internet: The relationship between
Internet
communication and depression, loneliness, self-esteem, and perceived
support. Cyber
Psychology
and Behavior, 5 (2): 157-171.
Shier, M. T.
(2005). The way technology changes how we do what we do. New
Directions for Student
Services: Whiley Periodicals, Inc. 2005(112), 77-87.
Silverman, T.
(2001). Expanding community: The Internet and relational theory.
Community,
Work & Family, 4 (2): 231-238.
Smith, M. &
Winking-Diaz, A. (2004). Increasing students’ interactivity in an
online course. The Journal
of Interactive Online Learning, 2 (3).
Subrahmanyam, K.,
Greenfield, P., Kraut, R., & Gross, E. (2001). The impact of
computer use on
children’s and adolescents’ development. Applied Development
Psychology, 22, 7- 30.
Suzuki, L. K., &
Carlo, J. P. (2004). The search for peer advice in cyberspace: An
examination of
online teenbulletin boards about health and sexuality. Applied Developmental
Psychology, 25, 685-698.
Tubaishat, A. et
al. (2006). ICT experience in two different Middle Eastern
universities. Issues in
Informing Science and Information Technology, 3: 667-678.
Turow, J. (1999).
The Internet and the family: The view from the parents, the view
from the press (Report
No. 27, May 4th). Philadelphia: Annenberg Public Policy
Center of the University of
Pennsylvania. Retrieved July 8, 2008, from
http://www.appcpenn.org
Turow, J., & Nir,
L. (2000). The Internet and the family: The view from parents the
view from kids.
Philadelphia: Annenberg Public Policy Center.
United Nations
(2005a). World youth report 2005: Young people today and in 2015.
Department of
Social and Economic Affairs. United Nations Publication: New York.
United Nations
(2005b). Youth, education, and employment. United Nations Economic
Commission for
Africa. United Nations Publication: New York.
Valkenburg, P. M.,
& Soeters, K. E. (2001). Children’s positive and negative
experiences with the
Internet: An exploratory survey. Communication Research, 28,
652-675.
Walsh, E., Gazala,
M., & Ham, C. (2001). The truth about the digital divide. In B.
Compaine (Ed.), The
digital divide: Facing a crisis or creating a myth? 279-284. The MIT
Press: Cambridge, MA.
Weiser, E. B.
(2001). The functions of Internet use and their social and
psychological consequences.
Cyber Psychology and Behavior, 4(6), 723-743.
Wheeler, D. L.
(2003). The Internet and youth subculture in Kuwait. JCMC 8(2):
retrieved from:
http://jcmc.indiana.edu/vol8/issue2/wheeler.html
Wheeler, D. L.
(2001). The Internet and public culture in Kuwait. Gazette, 63
(2-3), 187-201.
Williams, F., Rice,
R. E., & Rogers, E. M. (1988). Research methods and the new media.
New York: Free
Press.
Yigitcanlar, T. and
Baum, S. (2006). Providing youth with skills, training and
employment opportunities
through ICT initiatives. World Bank:
http://www.mena.cp/.org/cpi/english/01news/naw1112060124.htm
Young, K. S.
(2001). Caught in the Net: How to recognize the signs of Internet
addiction and a winning
strategy for recovery. Wiley.com & Amazon.com retrieved on 6/24/2008
from
http://psychcentral.com/netaddiction
|