The Logics of Globalization:
Studies in International Communication,
by Anandam
Kavoori. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, 2009. ISBN
978-0-7391-2184-9, 230 pp.
If there is
one word that has become the currency among scholars, journalists,
and policymakers in the past 20 years, it is globalization.
From terrorism to the environment, HIV-AIDS to H1N1 Flu epidemic,
free trade to protectionism, population growth to poverty and social
justice, globalization seems deeply implicated in nearly all of the
major issues of the new millennium. Some equate globalization merely
with free markets; others use the term interchangeably with concepts
such as transnationalism or postnationalism. However one defines
globalization, everyone acknowledges that today the world is a
different place. People’s experiences are linked to economic
realities, social processes, technological and media innovations and
cultural flows that traverse national boundaries with ever greater
momentum. Scholars acknowledge that globalization has been
responsible for major transformations of media and communication
processes around the world. Kavoori’s book is one such effort at
providing readers theoretical and methodological tools for
understanding issues of global media representations.
Studies of
globalization, in the discipline of Communication, has been
primarily aligned to an area loosely and broadly categorized as
International Communication. International Communication, Kavoori
writes, has been at the interstices of a wider set of debates
within/across its antecedent disciplines such as comparative
literature, sociology, international politics, anthropology and
"mirrors all the anxieties that bedevil those disciplines" (p. 2).
International Communication has also remained, according to Kavoori,
largely derivative where global media and communication theories
draw on and retrofit older models of world systems, political
economy, transnational ethnography and reception analysis. This has
resulted in a "theoretical and epistemic ambiguity" (p. 4) emergent
in borrowing from a wide set of transnational concerns without an
overarching frame to locate them. What scholars in International
Communication need, Kavoori argues, is an epistemic "re-strategization"
(p. 4) which is not only aimed at a critical engagement with
theories of the past but also an attempt at "blending the literature
and ideas from a wide range of fields but more crucially centering
communication at the international level as the framework for
thinking through the complexities and contradictions of our
collective global moment" (p. 2). In an attempt to develop such a
theoretical terrain Kavoori gives us the "International
Communication Prism" (p. 4) as vocabulary that centers communication
and globalization in our understanding of the word/world and engages
five conceptual terms from the institutional history of comparative
scholarship. Those terms are: modernism, postmodernism, capitalism,
nationalism, postcolonialism and terrorism. "I refer to these as the
logics of globalization," writes Kavoori, "…these terms represent
cultural, economic, and social forces that are present on the global
level irrespective of where a speaker/text/practice is located" (p.
6). Thereafter, Kavoori uses the logics of globalization as a
replacement for the word globalization which renders "visibility to
social action, provides order to community formation, and motivation
to change them" (p. 17).
In the six
chapters of the book, Kavoori pursues wide-ranging technologies and
media forms to translocate and explain the significant theoretical
usage of the International Communication Prism, in media forms which
range from early film-songs of Indian actor and director Raj Kapoor,
cricket, to cell phone advertising and gaming industry. Purpose of
the chapters is to "look at one or more logics and their creative
correlations with one or more media technologies, practices and
sites" (p. 16). International Communication Prism, thus, is a route
that takes readers away from the determinative nature of studying
International Communication, to a more creative, hermeneutically
based effort where the focus is on the process rather than on
the conclusions. After giving readers a groundwork of International
Communication Prism in chapter one, chapter two titled, "Singing in
a (New) Nation: The Early Films of Raj Kapoor", the author gives us
a textual analysis of several songs from Raj Kapoor’s early films,
to juxtapose national identity with media history and globalization.
Chapter three and four, respectively titled, "Time to Kill: Gaming
and Terrorism" and "Tracking the Authentic: World Music and the
Global Postmodern" provides the reader with additional textual
analyses of the content of several PC games (Deus Ex,
Ghost Recon and America’s Army) and music of several
musicians (such as Ali Farka Toure, Cesaria Evora and Nusrut Fateh
Ali Khan). In Chapters 5 and 6 titled, "Playing with Postcoloniality:
Four Moments in Indian Cricket" and "Consuming Technologies: The
Discourse of Cell Phone Advertising in India" focus is on analyzing
the game of cricket and advertising in postcolonial India.
The strength
of the book lies in the author’s attempt to uproot International
Communication from older theories of dependency, functionalism,
effects, world systems and so forth, to a theory which is
relational, "communication between" (p. 3) where media industries,
policies, movements and media forms coalesce. The book is a
stimulating read in its brave attempt to theoretically move
International Communication in new directions, especially in
addressing questions of postcoloniality, nationalism, hybridity and
terrorism; it is a compelling argument that International
Communication as a field needs reorientation.
Where the
book fails is in its execution. In Chapter 5, for instance, the
author spends several pages giving the reader an exhaustive history
of India’s cricket and cricketers and juxtaposes its importance to
the evolution of Hindu nationalism and masculinity. The conclusive
paragraph of the chapter ends with questions such as "How might have
an Indian nation developed without cricket?", "How might a film
about the Indian women’s cricket team be narrativized?" and "How
might it counter the masculinized story of cricket in India?" (p.
166). While the chapter begins with a brief, albeit perfunctory,
reading of postcolonial theory (major theorists are confined to
footnotes), the theorization itself gets diluted in the incessant
textual analysis of media representations randomly picked from the
author’s memory growing up in India. There are brief discussions of
several films where cricket has been depicted but the chapter closes
with a tangential question, "What modes of discursive accountability
account for the fact that there have been very few genuinely fast
bowlers to have emerged out of the Indian encounter with cricket?"
(p. 163) The emphasis of postcolonial theorists on unequal and
uneven forces of cultural representations and its ideological
interventions in modern Humanities and Social Sciences are lost in
Kavoori’s zealous analysis of the game of cricket. Such problems of
translocating International Communication Prism and its logics
(modernism, postcolonialism, capitalism, etc) to specific media
forms, practice or representation plagues each chapter. There is
never a clear reasoning as to why some PC games, musicians or films
are selected and analyzed over others. By the end of the book, one
is left with a shell of a theory which appears to have travelled
nowhere. This is particularly evident in two lengthy appendices
included at the end of the book. These two appendices titled,
"Travel Journalism and the Logics of Globalization" and "India Night
in Georgia: Why the Dancing Diasporic Desi Men Cross-Dressed" could
be read as chapters but it is never explained as to why they are
appendices and their pointed relevance to the rest of the book.
While I would
recommend the book for those interested in International
Communication in elucidating an insightful theory, the model itself
needs more contextualization before its relevance is clear to
students and scholars.